Smartphones have helped tens of thousands of migrants
travel to Europe. A phone means you can stay in touch with your family –
or with people smugglers. On the road, you can check Facebook groups
that warn of border closures, policy changes or scams to watch out for.
Advice on how to avoid border police spreads via WhatsApp.
Now, governments are using migrants' smartphones to deport them.
Across
the continent, migrants are being confronted by a booming mobile
forensics industry that specialises in extracting a smartphone’s
messages, location history, and even WhatsApp data. That information can
potentially be turned against the phone owners themselves.
In
2017 both Germany and Denmark expanded laws that enabled immigration
officials to extract data from asylum seekers’ phones. Similar
legislation has been proposed in Belgium and Austria, while the UK and
Norway have been searching asylum seekers’ devices for years.
Following right-wing gains across the EU, beleaguered
governments are scrambling to bring immigration numbers down. Tackling
fraudulent asylum applications seems like an easy way to do that. As
European leaders met in Brussels last week to thrash out a new, tougher framework to manage migration —which nevertheless seems insufficient
to placate Angela Merkel's critics in Germany— immigration agencies
across Europe are showing new enthusiasm for laws and software that
enable phone data to be used in deportation cases.
Admittedly,
some refugees do lie on their asylum applications. Omar – not his real
name – certainly did. He travelled to Germany via Greece. Even for
Syrians like him there were few legal alternatives into the EU. But his
route meant he could face deportation under the EU's Dublin regulation,
which dictates that asylum seekers must claim refugee status in the
first EU country they arrive in. For Omar, that would mean settling in
Greece – hardly an attractive destination considering its high
unemployment and stretched social services.
Last year, more than 7,000 people were deported
from Germany according to the Dublin regulation. If Omar’s phone were
searched, he could have become one of them, as his location history
would have revealed his route through Europe, including his arrival in
Greece.
But before his asylum interview, he met Lena –
also not her real name. A refugee advocate and businesswoman, Lena had
read about Germany’s new surveillance laws. She encouraged Omar to throw
his phone away and tell immigration officials it had been stolen in the
refugee camp where he was staying. “This camp was well-known for
crime,” says Lena, “so the story seemed believable.” His application is
still pending.
Omar is not the only asylum seeker to
hide phone data from state officials. When sociology professor Marie
Gillespie researched phone use among migrants travelling to Europe in
2016, she encountered widespread fear of mobile phone surveillance.
“Mobile phones were facilitators and enablers of their journeys, but
they also posed a threat,” she says. In response, she saw migrants who
kept up to 13 different SIM cards, hiding them in different parts of
their bodies as they travelled. READ MORE
No comments:
Post a Comment